A guide to the issues SMSF Trustees must understand first, before working on a SMSF owned property.
SONAS WEALTH | THE SMSF COACH Last reviewed: 16 November 2026 · Rules as at 16 November 2026; figures as at 1 July 2026 (2026–27)
SMSF TRUSTEE EDUCATION SERIES
By Liam Shorte | Fellow SMSF Specialist Advisor™ | Financial Planner
Answer: Yes, for work you do as trustee: organising trades, getting quotes and minor maintenance. Doing substantial trade work yourself is different, especially by a licensed tradie who doesn’t charge the fund properly. It can make all rent and capital gains from that property non-arm’s length income, taxed at 45 per cent under s.295-550 of the ITAA 1997, even in retirement phase.

| ⚖️ General Advice Disclaimer This article is general information only and does not constitute personal financial, legal or tax advice. The rules governing SMSFs are complex and individual circumstances vary significantly. You should obtain advice from a licensed financial adviser before acting on anything in this article. The author holds AFSL authorisation through Sonas Wealth Pty Ltd, corporate authorised representative of Viridian Advisory 476223. |
Who does this apply to?
This article is for trustees of self managed super funds that own residential or commercial property directly or under a limited recourse borrowing arrangement (LRBA). It covers work on the fund’s property by members, their relatives and their businesses. The answer changes if you are a licensed tradesperson, if the property is held under an LRBA, or if the work changes what the property is. It does not cover large APRA-regulated funds, which are outside the expenditure rules discussed here. first tip, always ask your accountant, adviser or fund auditor first!
If I’m capable of doing the work, why is it a problem?
Because the test isn’t skill! It’s whether the SMSF is dealing on arm’s length terms. Free or cheap work from a you or any related party can mean the fund pays less than an unrelated party would charge, and the tax law treats that shortfall seriously.
NALI and NALE in plain terms
Non-arm’s length income (NALI) under s.295-550 of the ITAA 1997 is taxed at 45 per cent, the top marginal rate. Since 1 July 2018 the rule also catches non-arm’s length expenditure (NALE): where the fund incurs less expense than it would at arm’s length, the income connected to that expense can become NALI.
Specific Expense Breaches: If the undercharged or free service is tied to earning income from a specific asset (e.g., you do free maintenance or property management on an SMSF-owned commercial or residential building), all ordinary and statutory income (including net capital gains) from that specific asset can be classified as NALI and taxed at 45%.
General Expense Breaches: If the free or discounted work is a general fund expense (not tied to a single asset), the NALI amount is capped using a general expenditure multiplier (up to a 5x shortfall factor, resulting in an effective tax penalty of up to 225% on the expense difference, or capped by the fund’s overall taxable income calculations).
Renovation work on a single property is a specific expense. If it is non-arm’s length, the ATO’s view in Law Companion Ruling LCR 2021/2 is that it has a sufficient connection to all income from that property, including any capital gain when it is sold. The 45 per cent rate then applies to the net rent and the gain, not just to the value of the free work. NALI is also excluded from the exempt current pension income rules, so it is taxed at 45 per cent even when the property supports a retirement phase pension.
Trustee capacity versus personal capacity
Section 17A of the SIS Act generally stops trustees being paid for their duties. Section 17B is the exception: a trustee can be paid for services provided in another capacity, but only if they are appropriately qualified and licensed, provide the same services to the public in the ordinary course of a business, and charge no more than an arm’s length rate.
LCR 2021/2 builds on this. The ATO presumes you are acting as trustee when you do work for your fund, and using your own skills or knowledge does not by itself change that. The ATO says you are more likely to be acting in your personal or professional capacity when:
- you charge the fund for the work
- you make material use of business equipment or assets (minor, occasional use of your tools does not count on its own)
- the work is done under a licence or qualification connected to your business or profession
- the work is covered by your business or professional insurance.
If you act as trustee and don’t charge, the NALE rules are not triggered. The September 2025 final version of the ruling added a second concession: if you act in your personal capacity but s.17B would prohibit the fund paying you (for example, you’re not licensed or you don’t run a business offering that service), the NALE rules do not apply to the unpaid work either.
The exposure sits with trustees who meet s.17B, typically working tradies and professionals, and who do the work for free or at a discount. They could lawfully charge the fund, so not charging is a non-arm’s length shortfall.
What can I safely do myself?
Managing the project is part of being a trustee. Choosing and briefing trades, getting quotes, signing contracts in the fund’s name, inspecting the work and approving invoices for payment from the fund’s bank account are trustee duties. So is minor upkeep with your own basic tools, like changing a tap washer or patching a wall.
Risk rises as the work gets bigger, more skilled and closer to something you would normally charge for. The table below reflects general SMSF industry practice and how auditors tend to view these activities. It is practical guidance, not a legal rule, and your facts can move an activity up or down.
| Activity by a member | Typical risk | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Organising trades, quotes and inspections | Low | Core trustee duty |
| Minor repairs with your own basic tools | Low | Treated as trustee capacity in the ATO’s examples |
| Painting a room yourself | Low to moderate | Usually maintenance; check for contribution and cost records |
| Landscaping over several weekends | Moderate | Can add value; materials must be bought by the fund |
| Installing a kitchen yourself | Moderate to high | Substantial work, significant materials, possible value increase |
| A licensed builder, electrician or plumber doing trade work free or at a discount | High | Likely personal capacity and specific NALE |
| Major structural work by a member | High | NALE, contributions, s.66 and LRBA issues can all arise |
Why materials are treated differently from labour
If you buy materials yourself and they end up in the fund’s property, the fund has acquired an asset from a related party. Section 66 of the SIS Act prohibits that unless an exception applies, and building materials are not one of them. SMSFR 2010/1 treats insignificant materials (a washer, a few screws) as part of a service, but significant materials such as a new bathroom’s fixtures as an acquisition. Paying market value does not fix it. The fund must buy materials directly from the supplier, be invoiced in its own name and pay from its own account.
Labour has its own trap. Under TR 2010/1, a contribution is anything of value that increases the fund’s capital. Where a member’s work increases the value of a fund asset, the ATO can treat the increase in value as a contribution, counted when the improvement becomes a fixture. That counts toward your contribution caps (for 2026–27, the non-concessional cap is $130,000, subject to your total super balance). Work that doesn’t add to the fund’s capital, such as preparing the fund’s accounts, is not a contribution.
I’m a tradie. Can I work on my fund’s property for free?
This is where the ATO focuses. If you are licensed, run a trade business and offer that service to the public, you meet s.17B and could lawfully charge your fund. Doing substantial work for free or at a discount then looks like specific NALE.
The ATO’s own Example 9 in LCR 2021/2 shows the line. Trang is a plumber, a sole trader with an apprentice, and the sole member of her SMSF, which owns two rental properties. After work one evening she connects a tenant’s water filter at one property, using a few of her tools and charging nothing. That is minor and occasional, so she acts as trustee and there is no NALE. At the second property she schedules a full kitchen and bathroom renovation in her work calendar, does all the plumbing with her trade tools, brings in her apprentice and charges nothing. The ATO concludes she is acting in her individual capacity. The rent from that property, and any capital gain when it is sold, is NALI.
Example 10 shows the clean alternative. Jean, a licensed electrician, does electrical work on his fund’s residential property that only a licensed electrician can do. He invoices the fund at his normal commercial rate, so there is no NALE.
If you want to use your own trade skills, charge the fund a documented market rate through your business, keep the invoice and have the fund pay it from its own account. A retired tradie who no longer runs a business is in a different position, because s.17B wouldn’t let the fund pay them, but the contribution and materials rules above still apply.
What changes if the property is under an LRBA?
Borrowed money can repair and maintain the property, but it can’t improve it. Fund cash can pay for improvements, as long as the work doesn’t turn the property into a different asset. Both limits come from s.67A of the SIS Act, and the ATO explains them in SMSFR 2012/1.
A repair fixes damage or deterioration. Maintenance prevents it. Replacing a dated but working kitchen with a modern equivalent is usually maintenance. An improvement significantly changes the property’s state or function for the better. Under SMSFR 2012/1, adding a bedroom, an extension, a pool or a granny flat in the backyard of a house are improvements that can still leave you with the same asset. Building on a vacant block, replacing a house with strata-titled units, or converting a house into a restaurant creates a different asset.
| Work and funding source | Allowed under an LRBA? |
|---|---|
| Repairs or maintenance paid from fund cash | Yes |
| Repairs or maintenance paid from LRBA borrowings | Yes (s.67A) |
| Improvements paid from fund cash | Yes, if the property remains the same asset |
| Improvements paid from LRBA borrowings | No |
| Any work that creates a different asset | No: the asset falls outside the borrowing exception, whatever the funding source |
If the asset changes character, the ATO’s view is that the fund no longer holds the asset the borrowing was for. That puts the fund in breach of the s.67 borrowing prohibition, and the usual fix is selling the asset and closing the arrangement. Note that the fund needs its own cash for improvements. A member paying for them personally brings the s.66 and contribution problems back in.
Can we stay at the property during the renovation?
No. A residential property in an SMSF must satisfy the sole purpose test in s.62 of the SIS Act, which the ATO explains in SMSFR 2008/2. Members and their relatives can’t live in it, stay in it or holiday in it, before, during or after the work. That includes sleeping over on weekends while you supervise the trades. Leasing it to a related party also makes it an in-house asset under s.71, and because it is residential that lease is very unlikely to fit within the 5 per cent limit.
Case study: a carpenter, an LRBA and a tired rental
This is a fictional example for illustration only but I see way to many of these in real life!!
Sam is a licensed carpenter who runs his own business. He and his partner Priya are the members of an SMSF in accumulation phase. The fund owns an $800,000 rental house bought under an LRBA, with gross rent of $35,000 a year. The kitchen cabinet doors are worn out, the bathroom leaks and they would like to add a deck. Sam reckons he can do the lot over a few months of weekends, work he would normally invoice a client about $40,000 for.
First, the LRBA. Replacing the kitchen cabinet doors and fixing the bathroom with modern equivalents is repair and maintenance, so borrowings could fund it. The deck is an improvement, so it must come from the fund’s own cash. None of it changes the house into a different asset. The fund has $60,000 in cash outside the loan, so funding works.
Second, who does the work. Sam meets s.17B: he is licensed, runs a carpentry business and offers the same work to the public. If he does it free with his trade tools, his situation looks like Trang’s in the ATO’s Example 9: specific NALE, with the rent and the eventual capital gain taxed as NALI. Buying the timber and fixtures through his business account adds a s.66 problem.
The clean option is for the fund to contract an unrelated builder, or for Sam’s business to quote and invoice the fund at his normal rate. Either way, the contract is in the fund’s name, materials are invoiced to the fund, and the fund pays every invoice from its own bank account. Priya and Sam can still organise the trades and inspect the work as trustees.
What would getting it wrong cost?
Assume Sam does the work free, the fund earns net rent of $15,000 a year after loan interest and other deductions, and it sells the house 10 years later for a $300,000 capital gain. The fund is a complying super fund, so it gets the one-third CGT discount, leaving a $200,000 net capital gain. Under TD 2024/5 the discount is applied before the non-arm’s length portion is worked out, so NALI is taxed on the discounted gain.
| Over 10 years (illustrative) | Normal SMSF tax (accumulation, 15%) | Taxed as NALI (45%) | Extra tax |
|---|---|---|---|
| Net rent: $15,000 a year for 10 years ($150,000) | $22,500 | $67,500 | $45,000 |
| Capital gain: $300,000, less one-third discount ($200,000) | $30,000 | $90,000 | $60,000 |
| Total | $52,500 | $157,500 | $105,000 |
If the fund were wholly in retirement phase when it earned this income, the normal tax would usually be nil, because the income would be exempt current pension income. As NALI, the full $157,500 would still be payable. Saving $40,000 on labour could cost the fund $105,000 to $157,500 in tax. The whole gain is caught, including growth from before the renovation, because s.295-550 has no mechanism to apportion it.
Assumptions: rent and deductions are flat; NALI treatment starts from the renovation; no capital losses; tax figures ignore the Medicare levy (which does not apply to super funds) and any Division 296 tax on members’ earnings.
What happens if we get it wrong?
The tax cost is usually the biggest hit, but it isn’t the only one. Your auditor must report certain contraventions to the ATO in an auditor contravention report, and the ATO then decides how to respond.
The ATO’s options under the SIS Act include:
- Rectification direction (s.159): for example, getting a valuation of work done, unwinding a related-party purchase or, under an LRBA, selling the asset. Failing to comply is a strict liability offence.
- Education direction (s.160): completing approved trustee education within a set time.
- Enforceable undertaking (s.262A): a written commitment from the trustees to fix the problem, which the ATO can enforce in court.
- Administrative penalties (s.166): imposed on each individual trustee personally.
- Disqualification (s.126A): removing a person’s right to act as an SMSF trustee or director.
- Notice of non-compliance: for serious breaches, the fund loses its complying status and its assets and income are taxed at 45 per cent.
Administrative penalties are set in penalty units. The Commonwealth penalty unit is $364 for contraventions on or after 1 July 2026 (it was $330 from 7 November 2024). The amounts most relevant to renovations are:
| Breach (SIS Act) | Penalty units | Per trustee from 1 July 2026 |
|---|---|---|
| s.67(1) borrowing prohibition (for example, an LRBA asset that becomes a different asset) | 60 | $21,840 |
| s.84(1) in-house asset rules (for example, a lease to a related party) | 60 | $21,840 |
| s.34(1) operating standards (for example, failing to keep fund assets separate) | 20 | $7,280 |
| s.103 minutes and records | 10 | $3,640 |
With individual trustees, each trustee is liable for their own penalty, so a two-member fund faces double. With a corporate trustee, one penalty applies and the directors are jointly and severally liable. Penalties can’t be paid or reimbursed from fund assets.
Section 66 is not on the administrative penalty list, but that doesn’t make a related-party acquisition harmless. It is a reportable contravention, it can lead to a rectification direction, and in serious cases it can be prosecuted as an offence.
What we see in practice
- A trustee who bought $14,000 worth of building materials from Bunnings on a personal card and never reimbursed those costs from the SMSF. The Auditor picked this up and we had to deal with s.66 at audit;
- An electrician member of the SMSF who assumed free labour was ok to gift to the fund as it “was only 2 days work”. We caught this on time and had him invoice the fund for his normal rates which amounted to $2,430 materials (I’m in the wrong career!). We only caught this one early because the spouse asked us if they could still claim the GST on some of the materials used and paid for by the fund (a least that was done properly!).
- An LRBA client who wanted to add a second dwelling to their investment property to run their own Physio business from. Their research said it was ok to add a Granny Flat so they engaged the builder before asking us. As this was to be used in their business, then while under an LRBA it breached the rules as it changed the nature of the property from being a residential property to a mixed use residential and business property. We had to unwind the LRBA by making contributions to the fund to pay off the loan, put a lease in place to his business and do an early voluntary disclosure to the ATO.
Your renovation checklist
First stop is to read out article SMSF Borrowing: What Can I Do With An Investment Property Within The Rules.
- Confirm whether the property is held under an LRBA, and classify each job as repair, maintenance or improvement.
- Check the fund has enough cash outside the loan for any improvements.
- Confirm the work won’t change the property into a different asset.
- Decide who does the work. If a member or relative is licensed and in business, either use an unrelated contractor or have their business invoice the fund at market rates.
- Put contracts and quotes in the fund’s name.
- Have every supplier invoice the fund directly, and never buy materials personally or through a related business.
- Pay every cost from the fund’s bank account.
- Get a valuation before and after any member-performed work that could add value, and track the contribution caps.
- Keep the property vacant of members and relatives throughout.
- Minute the trustee decisions and keep all quotes, invoices and valuations for your auditor.
Frequently asked questions
Can I paint the SMSF property myself?
Usually, yes. Painting is generally maintenance, and doing it yourself without charge is likely to be treated as acting in your trustee capacity. Have the fund buy the paint and supplies directly. If you’re a professional painter using your business equipment, treat it as trade work and get advice first.
Can my son, who is a builder, do the work instead of me?
Your son is a related party of your fund. If his business does the work free or at a discount, the specific NALE risk is the same as if you did it, and materials he supplies raise s.66. The fix is the same too: a written contract with the fund at market rates, invoiced to and paid by the fund.
Does a discount from an unrelated builder create NALI?
Not if it is a genuine commercial discount that any customer in the same position could get, such as a standard trade or volume discount. The ATO accepts discounts consistent with normal commercial practice. The concern is a discount that exists because of a relationship between the builder and the trustees.
Can the fund pay me for managing the renovation?
No. Organising trades, approving quotes and supervising work are trustee duties, and s.17A of the SIS Act stops trustees being paid for them. The upside is that doing them yourself without charge does not trigger the NALE rules.
We’ve already done the work ourselves. What now?
Speak with your adviser and accountant before the fund’s financial statements are prepared, not at audit. The right response depends on who did the work, who paid for materials and whether an LRBA is involved. Don’t create backdated invoices or agreements. Accurate records of what happened are the starting point for any fix. Don’t be afraid to make an Early Voluntary Disclosure to the ATO once you have documented and rectified the issues (go with a solution not a problem)
Your next step
Before you sign a contract or buy a single tile, book an SMSF property review with Sonas Wealth. We’ll check how the work can be funded under your LRBA, who should do which jobs, and the paperwork your auditor will want to see. Make a first appointment here
Sources:
Sources
- LCR 2021/2 Non-arm’s length income: expenditure incurred under a non-arm’s length arrangement (ATO legal database) and the original 2021 PDF, Examples 9 and 10
- Section 17B, Superannuation Industry (Supervision) Act 1993 (AustLII)
- ATO: Rules on assets under LRBAs
- ATO: How we deal with non-compliance
- LCR 2021/2 compendium of comments
- s.295-550 ITAA 1997: AustLII’s Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 – Section 295.550
- SMSFR 2012/1: ATO Legal Database – SMSFR 2012/1.
- SMSFR 2010/1: ATO Legal Database – SMSFR 2010/1.
- SMSFR 2008/2: ATO Legal Database – SMSFR 2008/2.
- TR 2010/1: ATO Legal Database – TR 2010/1.
- TD 2024/5: ATO Legal Database – TD 2024/5.
Are you looking for advisors that will keep you up to date and provide guidance and tips like in this blog? then why not contact us at our Castle Hill or Windsor office in North West Sydney to arrange a one-on-one consultation, just click the Schedule Now button up on the left to find the appointment options.
Please consider passing on this article to family or friends. Pay it forward!
Liam Shorte B.Bus FSSA™ AFP
Financial Planner & Fellow SMSF Specialist Advisor™


- Tel: 02 9899 3693, Mobile: 0413 936 299
- PO Box 6002 NORWEST NSW 2153
- Suite 40, 8 Victoria Ave, Castle Hill NSW 2154
- Suite 4, 1 Dight St., Windsor NSW 2756
Corporate Authorised Representative of Viridian Advisory Pty Ltd ABN 34 605 438 042, AFSL 476223
Important information
This article is general information only and does not constitute personal financial, legal, or taxation advice. The rules governing self-managed superannuation funds are complex and fact-specific. Individual circumstances vary significantly, and the application of the rules described in this guide depends on facts that can only be properly assessed by a qualified professional. Before establishing or participating in a structure of this type, seek advice from a licensed SMSF adviser and an experienced tax lawyer. Past tax outcomes are not a guide to future tax treatment.
































